What both share
Five axes, adjustable stick resistance, a throttle that detaches, and two ways to get rudder: twist the grip or tilt the lever on the throttle. Both have the RJ12 port for TFRP pedals.
What changed in August 2026
MSFS 2024 changed the PS5 profiles for both sticks. Thrustmaster’s article says the Hotas 5 in Blue mode is no longer detected as a Hotas 4, custom profiles made before the update are gone, and the Hotas 5 in Red mode needs a custom profile. Owner reports and fixes are in the Sim Update 6 guide.
How owners describe them
Posts in the MSFS forum from late 2025 call the Hotas 4 usable but limited in build quality and precision for larger aircraft, and one owner of several Thrustmaster console sticks says they wear quickly. Those are individual opinions. In that thread the Hotas 4 was the only PS5 stick anyone named.
After the update, one owner reported the Hotas 5 in Red mode stopping responding mid-flight, and said Blue mode did not do that. It is a single report.
Pick by job
| Job | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Most buttons for views, flaps and autopilot | Hotas 5 | Two more buttons than the Hotas 4. |
| Lowest price or whichever is in stock | Hotas 4 | The two are close in capability; pick the one you can get. |
| Least profile trouble after the update | Hotas 4 | Both got new default profiles. The Hotas 5 in Red mode needs a custom one. |
| Flying airliners or Cessnas more than anything | TCA Sky Yoke | See the PS5 hub. |
Which one to buy
Buy the Hotas 5 MSFS Edition if the price is within a few dollars of the Hotas 4. Plan to build a custom profile for it.
Buy the Hotas 4 if it costs less or the Hotas 5 is out of stock. It is the stick Microsoft named at launch.
Buying through our Amazon links costs you nothing extra and helps keep MSFS Setup free. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Check the Hotas 5 MSFS Edition listing Check the Hotas 4 listing
Specs and modes come from Thrustmaster’s Hotas 5 page, its manual, the Hotas 4 page, the Hotas Neo article and the Amazon.com listings linked above. Owner views are from the MSFS forum thread on PS5 joystick choice and a Reddit thread. Checked October 13, 2026.